Will the paper book really be dead in five years?
Will the traditional book be dead in five years? According to technology guru Nicholas Negroponte, books printed in paper and ink will cease to exist in that timeframe. The founder of One Laptop per Child said in an interview this week that the conventional book simply won't scale to the volumes it needs to cope with increasing demand from the developing world.
Negroponte, who is also a founder of the MIT Media Lab, developed the One Laptop per Child initiative to get cheap computers to children in far-flung villages in the developing world. Kids in Africa in towns that don't even have electricity can use his solar-powered laptops to consume information and become digitally literate.
He argues that distributing conventional print and paper books to hundreds of millions of people without the infrastructure to support it will be impossible. Far better, he says, to send a laptop with 100 books on it - or 100 laptops, each with 100 different books. That would give children in an African village 10,000 books, which, as he points out, is far more than most of us had in elementary school.
Negroponte says that he much prefers reading newspapers on the iPad rather than in traditional hardcopy. It creates the opportunity to digest more information from more sources, and to get different points of view from a range of different perspectives. He even envisages a system where you could ‘dial in’ the kind of perspective that you wanted to hear in your daily digital newspaper.
Twitter was abuzz with comments from people saying that Negroponte has overestimated the importance of the e-book. The general consensus seems to be that the traditional book will be around for a long time to come. But judging from empirical evidence, he may be onto something.
With developments such as the Sony e-reader (a new one launched recently with a 6 inch touchscreen) and the Kindle, it does seem as though e-books' time has finally come. A plethora of readers is hitting the market, and even retailers such as Barnes and Noble are getting in on the act with their own devices.
We have certainly seen traditional physical formats die out in other areas after suitable electronic devices appeared to replace them. Film company Agfa went bankrupt in 2005 after failing to grasp the shift from chemical to digital photography, for example. And the CD may not be dead, but it's twitching a lot and looking somewhat blue in the face.
But, these things are always more nuanced than we might first think. Chemical photography still holds out in medium and large format studios, for example. And, although CDs may be in for a tough time, their precursor, vinyl, is making a comeback, especially on the independent music circuit.
I imagine that the ebook will take off considerably, not only in the developing world, but also in the developed one. However, there will always be room for the traditional paper book. On my bookshelf now, I can see a handful of large format photography books that I would only really appreciate in their current form. There are also some cookbooks that exist for me more as objects than simply as ways to convey information.
So, while Negroponte is almost right, there will always be a core type of book that we will want to caress, both with our eyes and our fingers. Nicholas, don't take that away from us.
Danny Bradbury, MSN Tech & Gadgets
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Posted by: DrVex007 | Oct 22, 2010 5:05:33 AM
Quite Simply. NO. The Paperbook will not be dead. Sure it will see reductions year over year, but ultimately, carrying a 5-8lb laptop around is not as easy as throwing a paperback in your purse or backpack.
If you are talking strictly school textbooks, then I think that the decline will happen much more quickly. For example, let's say a school were to sell a textbook for $100, but offer a download for $50. How many people would buy the book? The challenge though is that nobody is as resourceful as high school to college students, so they will find a way to copy that file and transmit it for free.
The technology is coming, but sitting under a tree and having more than a 2 hour battery life to read a book still has alot of value in my...... book.
Posted by: Nicholas Negroponte | Oct 22, 2010 8:58:58 AM
Dead is not the word. Rare is better. It will be like opera and ballet, for a rich elite. The developing world adopted cell phones long before we did. That was because they had no land lines. Likewise, they will adopt e-books, as they have no paper ones. Watch. And we will follow.
BTW: battery life on the XO (to pick one) is 22 hours reading a book in daylight. The cost of a textbook should and will be $1.00 or zero.
NN
Posted by: Cody | Oct 22, 2010 4:17:10 PM
The paper-bound book may die, but not any time soon. Ebooks are too difficult to read. It's WAY easier to flip through a book (textbook, resource book, etc) for the page you want, than it is to 'flip' through an ebook. Ebooks are simply not as powerful as they could be. Yes, they have bookmarks and chapter links, etc, but in large ebooks, finding a particular piece of information is often difficult. And, ebooks require an e-reader or laptop. Most people have laptops, but they are large, and their battery life is too short (read: thirty minutes after 2 years of use).
Until e-readers and the books they display become more versatile and more in people's price range, the traditional book will not die.
And, when electronic reading is more accessible, traditional books will become collector's items, not trash.
Posted by: Thia | Oct 23, 2010 12:05:43 PM
I can see it now second hand book stores get ready for expansion. so many books not enough time to read them.
So while I contemplate a Bebook purchase, mainly to save on my reading addiction, I just cannot envision getting rid of my enormous collection of paperbacks. They don't break if you accidentaly sit on them, and if the cat or dog bites them they'll probably live, If I drop them in a puddle I only need to dry it out for it to be readable, can the same be true of electronic books?
Someone in recent months said with digital and electronic media the product is constantly being updated, yet a book can last for centuries, so which device is truly effiecient.
As for the spread of books in third world countries, digital media will only survive as long as it take to be shot up by the local militia for spreading heresies. Thought, reason, and the ability to survive, war, starvation, and religious teaching will drive those willing to change and adapt out of their third world societies. Digital media is more likely to end up supporting the status quo.
Posted by: Long Ago | Oct 24, 2010 9:09:32 AM
Telling my grand kids two things:
The books I am about to give you, put away and hold them and pass them on to your children. They will be worth a fortune one day.
Do not have any aspirations to become Librarians.
I am sure books will become more expensive to produce and therefore buy, but will always be available for many of the reasons already outlined. Publishing will become more selective in what is produced and released in book form.
Posted by: Jamie J | Oct 26, 2010 4:39:27 PM
Personally, I stand by the perspective I gave my mother when she started hounding me to get an e-book and clear out my library. Nothing can replace the feel of a much loved paperback, the smell of fresh ink or old pages, or the sound of a page turning. And then there's the visual aspect: you see someone reading an e-book and the impression you get is that they're tech-savvy. You see someone with a book, and depending on the genre, language, title, author, etc, you get hundreds of different impressions. If the e-book takes over, which I doubt it will, people watching will certainly take a blow.
Posted by: Lulu | Oct 30, 2010 12:54:40 AM
I have to agree with NN, paperbooks will become rare, not disappear. From my perspective they will take the same route as the FAX machine; they are still used, but with each year that passes you see less and less of them.
Don't get me wrong, like many of you, I love the feel and smell and the page turning (especially when the book just pulls you in) that paper books provide, however, as a frequent traveller, I must say, having an ebook reader has done several things for me: 1) it has lightened my carry on and checked baggage. Gone are the days of 5-10 precious pounds of luggage real estate taken up by books/text books...have you carried a text book in a backpack for the mile walk to your departure gate recently...just think sweat! 2) it has decreased my need for accessory items, such as my itybity book light...my ereader has one built in. Yeah! More space in my carry on bag! 3) it has allowed me to travel with as many books as I want. I am a fast reader. It is not uncommon for me to read 3-4 books in a week when on vacation. Now, all I do is download the books I THINK I would like to read, and like magic, I have the pick of the crop. since I don't have to worry about space in my luggage, I can pick and choose as I please. 4) it has left me with a few more pennies in my wallet. E-books are much cheaper than paper books. Enough said on that topic.
I guarantee the next time I move, I won't have to add more boxes of books to the mix (between me and my hubby, we had over 30 boxes of books on our last move).
I love the paperbooks that I have, and if there is a special edition of something I feel worthy to place in my library, you bet your bottom dollar I will purchase it. But my "mindless drivel" books...the ones that entertain me because I like the characters, the romantic affairs that make my heart go pitter patter, and the likes, I am good with having those in ebook format and pay a fraction of the price.
For those that claim the e-readers are too costly...if you read as much as I do, you will pay for that ereader in a very short period of time just from the savings.
Posted by: Desktop Computers | Nov 12, 2010 9:41:06 AM
Your article contains a very true prediction. Paper book will be totally forbidden in a few couple of years. As I am very much against of it and as only my concerned I am never going to quit this habit. I admit that technology is increasing day by day but we are not supposed to forbid the things by which we reach at this point.
Posted by: Laptop Reviews | Feb 24, 2011 5:03:47 AM
We are in the world of new media and i believe its not the people who are opinion leader but the media. What we buy is what they decide. It is tangible. I mean if media creates a brand called ipad and people buy it than many other competitors use the same usp and jumps in the newly created market. They start selling their product by backing the promotional tools of SAVE TREES SAVE PAPERS. I wonder if by any means they mean it.
More and more technology is only going to create more and more aggressive minds.
Thanks
Prateek Panchal
Posted by: drupal website developer | Apr 26, 2011 2:30:31 AM
Its great informative blog.I am sure books will become more expensive to produce and therefore buy, but will always be available for many of the reasons already outlined.I agree media created a brand called ipad and many other competitors use the same USP in the newly created market.Thanks for finding time to share your ideas.
Posted by: plantronics wireless headset | May 25, 2011 5:29:55 PM
It was on the news the other day that paper books are fading away. It really was very interesting and the fact that I just ran into this article also, weird.
Posted by: telephone headset | May 25, 2011 5:32:35 PM
I agree though with this article, when I go to bookstores I notice that most are hard covers. The paper backs are becoming extinct.
Posted by: Logo design | Aug 9, 2011 3:03:11 AM
Well in my view personal paper book are still around and would still be in use even after five years. Particularly in developing countries paper books would be used for a long time to come.
Posted by: Oakley sunglasses | Aug 23, 2011 5:55:41 AM
The panic. Don't look down until the mind reading this article I suddenly gives.
Posted by: London Heathrow airport transfers to Oxford | Dec 15, 2011 4:54:53 AM
Great post! This is the first time I am visiting your site… Its cool and I like your template. More over, the quality of your posts are just awesome!
Posted by: Water Treatment Companies, NJ, PA, NY | Mar 15, 2012 6:34:19 AM
Great post. You have shared some really nice information with us.
Posted by: Long Beach Island Rentals | Mar 15, 2012 6:46:38 AM
You have done a really good job on this blog. You have presented the whole issue very well. I like it and admire it.
Posted by: Bounce House Rentals Georgia | Mar 15, 2012 7:18:28 AM
Great work. The whole blog is really good and particularly this post was tremendous. Keep it up.